Animal Train

Loading the player ...

This is a special video presentation called a videative. To experience this presentation as it is intended, read through the text on the right-hand side and click the hyperlinked words to automatically play the accompanying video segment.

Trouble playing video?

To darken the rest of the page while the video plays you can click "Turn off the lights" above. Alternatively, you can play the video at full screen by placing your cursor inside the video window to reveal the control bar and clicking the "enlarge" button on the far right.

What to Look for
Two children, each about two-years-old, play with blocks and small plastic animals. With Tucker’s help, Ayla builds a train for the animals to ride. George, the adult, engages the children, posing many questions in order to encourage Ayla and Tucker to reflect on their invented symbols. George’s goal is to help children think more about how things work (function) rather than how things look (description), and to motivate the children’s play toward a richer story where the characters have intentions and emotions.


The Story
The episode begins with George, Ayla, and Tucker in the block corner. Ayla has a vision for her creations with the blocks and plastic animals. In this first clip, Ayla identifies the cylindrical blocks as towers. George wants to know more about how she came to recognize them as such. Obviously they look like towers when standing tall on their vertical axes, but in the context of play what purpose do they serve?


Ayla says something about building the towers because “Annie and Callie knocked them over.” George thinks she says that she wants to knock them over, but Ayla is quick to correct George’s paraphrase. George changes his approach. He says, “If they are down [horizontal] like that, then they would not be towers, would they?” Ayla immediately stands the cylinder upright. Watch this portion of the video.


Tucker has a tall metal cylinder with a hole in it. He stands it up near the wooden cylinder. George wonders if the metal cylinder represents the same thing as the block, and asks, “Is that a tower?” Tucker says no, but George insists, “You stood it up like that [pointing to the wooden cylinder that Ayla previously identified].” George’s objective is to show Tucker that two objects that differ in material and detail might still serve as the same symbol.


Tucker proceeds to explain that his object is a drill. George wants to know what about this object identifies it as a drill instead of a tower. Tucker answers George’s questions by pointing out that this object has a hole. George then successfully moves Tucker beyond naming the static attributes of the object (“a hole”) to identifying the function of these attributes (Tucker rotates the object on George’s palm). Watch.


George senses that Ayla has definite ideas for where each toy animal goes; he holds out a large horse and seeks Ayla’s advice on where to place it. By seeking Ayla’s advice, George can begin to unpack her reasons for placing the objects where she does. When Ayla places the horse in its “special place” she does not say why the horse belongs there. This prompts George to play the “Why not here?” game. It takes two rounds of this game before Ayla demonstrates that her placement is not arbitrary. She finally says, “This horsey eats hay.” After saying this, Ayla places the horse next to a raised arch. This “better” special place could represent a hay trough. Ayla has thus “motivated” her placement and given richness to her symbolism. Watch.


Ayla lifts a giraffe and places it in a vacant space on the row of blocks near to her. Upon reflection, Ayla excitedly moves the small giraffe next to a larger one on the other side of the platform. George motivates her new placement, saying, “They want to be together.” This comment highlights the intention of the giraffe, not simply the physical proximity of the big and little animals.


After placing the giraffes together, Ayla develops the theme of togetherness. “They’re riding a train,” she says. Now, the aligned blocks represent train cars. George picks up on this theme and asks, “Where is the train going?” When Ayla answers, “The office,” George is surprised. He responds, “Not the circus or the zoo?” While this might lead the child away from her own theme, George chances that Ayla will consider George’s alternative without accepting it. Watch.


Tucker adds several animals to the top of the blocks. His placements seem to be based on the simple rule, “Put any toy in the closest vacant space.” Conversely, Ayla’s placements are guided by a more deliberate pairing of similar animals. When she encounters three similar lizards, she shifts to family roles. “Daddy, baby, and Momma,” are based on the relative size of the toy animals. George notices that she passes over the alligator in the middle of this group and asks her what the alligator is doing among the lizards. Ayla replies that it is there “because they love ’em.” She understands that the alligator does not belong to the group of lizards based on physical features, but by inventing a love-based reason for their proximity she has exchanged physical belonging for emotional belonging. Bravo! Watch.


Ayla knows Tucker well. When he drops his bear, Ayla picks it up and hands to him. She expects no reaction from Tucker; it appears she has retrieved his bear for him on many occasions. When Ayla accidentally knocks over one of the towers Tucker drops his bear to set the tower upright again. This time he picks the bear up on his own. Seeing Tucker hold the bear to his cheek, Ayla is moved to explain the bear’s significance to George. “That’s Tucker’s boo boo bear,” she says, gesturing toward Tucker. George then asks a question that is too difficult to answer, “What does that mean, ‘boo boo bear?’” Ayla’s response focuses on what she knows, “It’s a bear. That’s Tucker.” George thought that "boo boo bear” meant, “the bear you hold when you get hurt.” A better question might have been, “Why is his name boo boo?” This question is also difficult, but it is more focused on the intention behind the choice of name. Watch.


Tucker listens while Ayla and George discuss his boo boo bear and decides to interject something about his necklace. He announces to George, “I broke my necklace.” George looks over and sees that the
necklace is not truly broken. He approaches Tucker and asks sympathetically, “What’s wrong with it?” Tucker explains that previously his necklace contained many more beads. George wants to make Tucker’s comparison of the current necklace with few beads and the previous necklace with many beads more explicit, so he summarizes the contrast: “You lost a lot of the beads; you had more beads on it?” Tucker agrees with George’s summation. George had hoped that Tucker would consider the messages that words convey. If you say, “I broke my necklace,” and hold up a necklace that is not broken, more words of explanation are required.


George notices that one of the beads (shaped like a candy lifesaver) seems to serve as the joint between the two tied ends of the lanyard- necklace. George makes an attempt to find out if this bead has a special role (similar to his question about the animals having a special place). If it is a joint rather than a decorative bead, then maybe it should be placed in the back of the neck. Tucker may not have understood George’s question, or he may have simply wanted all the beads in the front where they could be seen. (After all, he only has three beads left!) Watch.


George points out the toy dog in an attempt to gather a reason for its placement in the middle of the other animals. George says, “He’s not happy all by himself.” Ayla quickly retorts, “He’s not happy yet,” implying that something nice will happen to him in the future. When pressed by George, Ayla explains that soon he will be near another dog; this is consistent with her theme of pairing similar animals. The storyline again moves from the physical to the psychological. George assumes the voice of the unhappy dog and, when George moves the dog to the top of the tower, Ayla objects. She wants the dog to be lower. Even though George does not catch her words at the time, the video captures her reasoning: “Because this is a choo-choo.” One can only speculate on her reasoning, but she might mean that if the train is going somewhere, the dog has to be on the train, not on the tower. Watch.


Ayla continues adding new toys to the aligned blocks, this time toy cars. If the blocks are train cars and the cars are road cars, why might they be on the train? George asks Ayla to explain this situation, which she does with her causal aplomb: the cars are going to the zoo. George reminds Ayla that she had said that the animals were going to the office. Perhaps Ayla has changed the train’s destination or maybe she has created a separate train. Tucker seems content to stay close by, listen, and watch how the story unfolds. Watch.


The play continues but soon the purpose changes. Tucker’s necklace really does come untied and what follows is a sweet scene with Ayla helping Tucker retie his necklace. But this is another story.


What We Have Learned
This eight-minute video includes a number of important ideas about the role of the teacher and the competence of children.


Here are some of the teaching principles we have observed:
  • Ask the children to explain their symbols: Does it have to be up to be a tower?

  • Give children “as opposed to” choices: Why not put the “horsey” here?

  • Add an emotional dimension to pretend play: This dog is not happy.

  • Motivate the play to give purpose and intention to the action: The giraffes’ togetherness

  • Gently confront children about the ambiguities of their statements: The unbroken necklace

  • Support a shift from description to an inference about function: The horsey eats hay.

  • Ask questions about how things work: How does the hole make it a drill?

  • Assume that the child has a reason for an action, then seek to uncover this reason: Why not place animals on top of towers?

  • Cross-reference a current statement with earlier statements: Going to the office or the zoo?

  • Ask children for their advice to discover their reasons: Where should I put the horse?


  • Here are some ideas about the children’s competence that we have observed:
  • Children are able to construct meaning if motivated: Animals stay low for a train ride

  • Children can resist counter-suggestions and justify their ideas: The horsey eats hay

  • Young children are aware of each other’s need for comfort: Tucker’s boo boo bear

  • Children have reasons for their actions; little is arbitrary: Animals are paired by type

  • Children are clever about how they make accidents seem like plans:Because they love the alligator

  • The quiet child has a lot to say when validated: Tucker talks about his necklace


  • To purchase a high resolution, continuous version of this video “click here”:What to Look for
    Two children, each about two-years-old, play with blocks and small plastic animals. With Tucker’s help, Ayla builds a train for the animals to ride. George, the adult, engages the children, posing many questions in order to encourage Ayla and Tucker to reflect on their invented symbols. George’s goal is to help children think more about how things work (function) rather than how things look (description), and to motivate the children’s play toward a richer story where the characters have intentions and emotions.


    The Story
    The episode begins with George, Ayla, and Tucker in the block corner. Ayla has a vision for her creations with the blocks and plastic animals. In this first clip, Ayla identifies the cylindrical blocks as towers. George wants to know more about how she came to recognize them as such. Obviously they look like towers when standing tall on their vertical axes, but in the context of play what purpose do they serve?


    Ayla says something about building the towers because “Annie and Callie knocked them over.” George thinks she says that she wants to knock them over, but Ayla is quick to correct George’s paraphrase. George changes his approach. He says, “If they are down [horizontal] like that, then they would not be towers, would they?” Ayla immediately stands the cylinder upright. Watch this portion of the video.


    Tucker has a tall metal cylinder with a hole in it. He stands it up near the wooden cylinder. George wonders if the metal cylinder represents the same thing as the block, and asks, “Is that a tower?” Tucker says no, but George insists, “You stood it up like that [pointing to the wooden cylinder that Ayla previously identified].” George’s objective is to show Tucker that two objects that differ in material and detail might still serve as the same symbol.


    Tucker proceeds to explain that his object is a drill. George wants to know what about this object identifies it as a drill instead of a tower. Tucker answers George’s questions by pointing out that this object has a hole. George then successfully moves Tucker beyond naming the static attributes of the object (“a hole”) to identifying the function of these attributes (Tucker rotates the object on George’s palm). Watch.


    George senses that Ayla has definite ideas for where each toy animal goes; he holds out a large horse and seeks Ayla’s advice on where to place it. By seeking Ayla’s advice, George can begin to unpack her reasons for placing the objects where she does. When Ayla places the horse in its “special place” she does not say why the horse belongs there. This prompts George to play the “Why not here?” game. It takes two rounds of this game before Ayla demonstrates that her placement is not arbitrary. She finally says, “This horsey eats hay.” After saying this, Ayla places the horse next to a raised arch. This “better” special place could represent a hay trough. Ayla has thus “motivated” her placement and given richness to her symbolism. Watch.


    Ayla lifts a giraffe and places it in a vacant space on the row of blocks near to her. Upon reflection, Ayla excitedly moves the small giraffe next to a larger one on the other side of the platform. George motivates her new placement, saying, “They want to be together.” This comment highlights the intention of the giraffe, not simply the physical proximity of the big and little animals.


    After placing the giraffes together, Ayla develops the theme of togetherness. “They’re riding a train,” she says. Now, the aligned blocks represent train cars. George picks up on this theme and asks, “Where is the train going?” When Ayla answers, “The office,” George is surprised. He responds, “Not the circus or the zoo?” While this might lead the child away from her own theme, George chances that Ayla will consider George’s alternative without accepting it. Watch.


    Tucker adds several animals to the top of the blocks. His placements seem to be based on the simple rule, “Put any toy in the closest vacant space.” Conversely, Ayla’s placements are guided by a more deliberate pairing of similar animals. When she encounters three similar lizards, she shifts to family roles. “Daddy, baby, and Momma,” are based on the relative size of the toy animals. George notices that she passes over the alligator in the middle of this group and asks her what the alligator is doing among the lizards. Ayla replies that it is there “because they love ’em.” She understands that the alligator does not belong to the group of lizards based on physical features, but by inventing a love-based reason for their proximity she has exchanged physical belonging for emotional belonging. Bravo! Watch.


    Ayla knows Tucker well. When he drops his bear, Ayla picks it up and hands to him. She expects no reaction from Tucker; it appears she has retrieved his bear for him on many occasions. When Ayla accidentally knocks over one of the towers Tucker drops his bear to set the tower upright again. This time he picks the bear up on his own. Seeing Tucker hold the bear to his cheek, Ayla is moved to explain the bear’s significance to George. “That’s Tucker’s boo boo bear,” she says, gesturing toward Tucker. George then asks a question that is too difficult to answer, “What does that mean, ‘boo boo bear?’” Ayla’s response focuses on what she knows, “It’s a bear. That’s Tucker.” George thought that "boo boo bear” meant, “the bear you hold when you get hurt.” A better question might have been, “Why is his name boo boo?” This question is also difficult, but it is more focused on the intention behind the choice of name. Watch.


    Tucker listens while Ayla and George discuss his boo boo bear and decides to interject something about his necklace. He announces to George, “I broke my necklace.” George looks over and sees that the
    necklace is not truly broken. He approaches Tucker and asks sympathetically, “What’s wrong with it?” Tucker explains that previously his necklace contained many more beads. George wants to make Tucker’s comparison of the current necklace with few beads and the previous necklace with many beads more explicit, so he summarizes the contrast: “You lost a lot of the beads; you had more beads on it?” Tucker agrees with George’s summation. George had hoped that Tucker would consider the messages that words convey. If you say, “I broke my necklace,” and hold up a necklace that is not broken, more words of explanation are required.


    George notices that one of the beads (shaped like a candy lifesaver) seems to serve as the joint between the two tied ends of the lanyard- necklace. George makes an attempt to find out if this bead has a special role (similar to his question about the animals having a special place). If it is a joint rather than a decorative bead, then maybe it should be placed in the back of the neck. Tucker may not have understood George’s question, or he may have simply wanted all the beads in the front where they could be seen. (After all, he only has three beads left!) Watch.


    George points out the toy dog in an attempt to gather a reason for its placement in the middle of the other animals. George says, “He’s not happy all by himself.” Ayla quickly retorts, “He’s not happy yet,” implying that something nice will happen to him in the future. When pressed by George, Ayla explains that soon he will be near another dog; this is consistent with her theme of pairing similar animals. The storyline again moves from the physical to the psychological. George assumes the voice of the unhappy dog and, when George moves the dog to the top of the tower, Ayla objects. She wants the dog to be lower. Even though George does not catch her words at the time, the video captures her reasoning: “Because this is a choo-choo.” One can only speculate on her reasoning, but she might mean that if the train is going somewhere, the dog has to be on the train, not on the tower. Watch.


    Ayla continues adding new toys to the aligned blocks, this time toy cars. If the blocks are train cars and the cars are road cars, why might they be on the train? George asks Ayla to explain this situation, which she does with her causal aplomb: the cars are going to the zoo. George reminds Ayla that she had said that the animals were going to the office. Perhaps Ayla has changed the train’s destination or maybe she has created a separate train. Tucker seems content to stay close by, listen, and watch how the story unfolds. Watch.


    The play continues but soon the purpose changes. Tucker’s necklace really does come untied and what follows is a sweet scene with Ayla helping Tucker retie his necklace. But this is another story.


    What We Have Learned
    This eight-minute video includes a number of important ideas about the role of the teacher and the competence of children.


    Here are some of the teaching principles we have observed:
  • Ask the children to explain their symbols: Does it have to be up to be a tower?

  • Give children “as opposed to” choices: Why not put the “horsey” here?

  • Add an emotional dimension to pretend play: This dog is not happy.

  • Motivate the play to give purpose and intention to the action: The giraffes’ togetherness

  • Gently confront children about the ambiguities of their statements: The unbroken necklace

  • Support a shift from description to an inference about function: The horsey eats hay.

  • Ask questions about how things work: How does the hole make it a drill?

  • Assume that the child has a reason .for an action, then seek to uncover this reason: Why not place animals on top of towers?

  • Cross-reference a current statement with earlier statements: Going to the office or the zoo?

  • Ask children for their advice to discover their reasons: Where should I put the horse?


  • Here are some ideas about the children’s competence that we have observed:
  • Children are able to construct meaning if motivated: Animals stay low for a train ride

  • Children can resist counter-suggestions and justify their ideas: The horsey eats hay

  • Young children are aware of each other’s need for comfort: Tucker’s boo boo bear

  • Children have reasons for their actions; little is arbitrary: Animals are paired by type

  • Children are clever about how they make accidents seem like plans: Because they love the alligator

  • The quiet child has a lot to say when validated: Tucker talks about his necklace

  • To purchase a continuous version of this video click here.



    Subjects: blocks

    Ages: twos

    Tags: children-teacher pretense classification function teaching